Shingle or standing seam metal: which roof is right for a South Texas home?

New shingle roof on a home in Pleasanton, Texas, by Rampant Roofing & Construction.
Pleasanton: new shingle roof

Both are good roofs. Shingles cost less up front and come in a wide range of colors and styles, which makes them a smart choice for most families. Standing seam metal costs more up front, but it lasts longer, stands up better to wind and reflects more of the summer sun. It makes the most sense if you plan to stay in your home for a long time.

If you're replacing your roof, this may be the biggest choice in the whole project. It's a lot of money either way. You want to get it right, and you don't want to feel pushed into the more expensive option.

What's the difference?

Shingle roofs are the most common roof on homes in South Texas. They go on in overlapping rows, and they come in a wide range of colors and styles to fit almost any house. As an Owens Corning Preferred Contractor, we install Owens Corning shingles.

Standing seam metal roofs are made of long metal panels that run from the peak of the roof down to the edge. The panels lock together at raised seams, and the fasteners are hidden under those seams instead of going through the face of the metal. We install standing seam in Galvalume, which has a bare silver finish, or in color.

New standing seam metal roof on a home in San Antonio, Texas, by Rampant Roofing & Construction.
San Antonio: new standing seam metal roof

Standing seam or screw-down metal?

Not every metal roof is standing seam. Many metal roofs are screw-down panels, where the screws go straight through the face of the metal and seal with rubber washers. Those washers are exposed to the weather, and over time they can wear and let water in.

On a standing seam roof, the fasteners sit under the raised seams, out of the sun and rain. When you compare metal roof quotes, ask which kind you're getting. Standing seam is what we install.

Cost up front

Shingles cost less to install. Metal costs more. How much more depends on the size and shape of your roof, so the only honest way to compare is to look at your roof and price both.

After a free inspection, we show you good, better and best options with clear prices, so you can see the difference for your own house instead of guessing.

How long you plan to stay

For a lot of families, this is the question that decides it. Metal lasts longer than shingles, so it pays off best when you'll be in the house long enough to get that value. If you might sell in the next few years, or the budget is tight right now, a quality shingle roof is the smarter buy.

Wind, heat and hail

South Texas is hard on a roof. Standing seam metal stands up better to high winds, and it reflects more of the summer sun instead of soaking it up.

Hail is hard on both. Big hail can dent metal, and it can crack or bruise shingles and knock off their granules. Neither roof is hail-proof. Whichever you choose, we'll check it for free after a storm and show you photos of what we find.

The look you want

Shingles come in a wide range of colors and styles, so it's easy to match your house and your neighborhood. Standing seam metal has clean, straight lines. It suits farmhouse and ranch homes especially well, and a colored metal roof can give an older house a whole new look.

If your neighborhood has a homeowners association, check its rules before you settle on metal or a new color. Some associations limit roof materials or colors, and it's easier to know before the work starts.

Warranties

Every shingle roof we install carries our 5-year workmanship warranty. Every standing seam metal roof carries our 10-year workmanship warranty.

On shingle roofs, as an Owens Corning Preferred Contractor, we can also offer Owens Corning's extended shingle warranties, System Protection and Preferred Protection. We'll explain what each one includes when we go over your options.

What goes under either roof

Whichever you choose, a new roof is only as good as what's under it. Under every roof is the decking, the layer of wood the roof is fastened to. If we find rotted decking during the tear-off, we photograph it, walk you through it and replace it, so your new roof goes down on solid wood.

How long installation takes

Most shingle roofs are replaced in one day. Standing seam metal takes three days or more, depending on the size of the roof, because each panel has to be measured and fitted to your roof. Either way, we'll tell you what to expect before we start.

A simple way to decide

Shingles are probably the better fit if:

  • You want the lower price up front
  • You might sell in the next few years
  • You want a particular color or style to match your house

Standing seam metal is probably the better fit if:

  • You plan to stay in your home for a long time
  • You want the most protection from high winds
  • You love the clean look of metal

Still not sure? That's normal. After a free inspection, we'll walk you through both options for your roof, with clear prices, and let you choose. At the end of the day, it's your home and your choice.

Shingle and metal roof questions

  • What's the difference between Galvalume and colored metal?

    Galvalume is metal with a bare silver finish. Colored metal has a painted finish in the color you choose. We install both, and both carry our 10-year workmanship warranty.

  • Do shingles or metal hold up better to hail?

    Neither is hail-proof. Big hail can dent metal and crack or bruise shingles. After any hailstorm, we'll inspect your roof for free and photograph what we find.

  • Can I see both options priced for my house?

    Yes. After a free inspection, we can price both for your roof, with good, better and best options and clear prices, so you can compare them side by side.

Jon Loya owns Rampant Roofing & Construction in Pleasanton, Texas. He has nearly seven years in roofing and runs the company with his dad, Manny, a Marine Corps veteran.

Let's find out what your roof needs.

Call Jon at (830) 569-7698, or request your free inspection online. We'll be at your house within 48 hours, weekends and holidays included.

Get my roof checkedIt's free, and we'll be at your house within 48 hours, weekends and holidays included.
Or call (830) 569-7698

Not ready yet? Get the free After the Storm checklist.

Thanks. Your checklist is on its way to your inbox.

Something went wrong. Please try again, or call us at (830) 569-7698.

Get my roof checked